A prominent question arose whether there would be major changes after this pope is gone. Analysts looked at the roster of the College of Cardinals and observed that the cardinals are relics of the past. They were inducted by either Pope John Paul II or Pope Benedict. They espouse the old ideas of their ‘mentors’. So the consensus emerged that given the pedigree and age of the cardinals, major reforms cannot be expected. Bummer!
Scientific research establishment is a living fossil. The scientific establishment, like the Church, is recalcitrant to change and resistant to new ideas. The policies, review processes, money allocation, research activities, hiring of scientists, publication of research papers, and the decisions on tenure and promotion of faculty are conducted in the spirit of medieval feudal system.
A scientist is supposed to push the boundaries of knowledge. Unfortunately, old duds on review committees’ rosters are impervious to new ideas. Some are mean and greedy who have outlived their scientific utility and are unable to grasp the explosion of knowledge in modern science. Many are insecure and are bitterly critical of new developments yet they pretend to be broad-minded. Others are fools who still hold on to the idea of ‘hypothesis driven research’ as sacred. Together, they have stymied the progress of science and emergence of new ideas more than any politician could ever do. Scientific progress cannot be achieved at its fullest if the research is to be judged by scientists entrenched in their archaic research ideas.
The question is not whether the old scientists sitting at the helm of affairs should be replaced by the young blood, but how soon it should be done. Take action, write to your elected representative. Every voice counts.